+86-15123173615

Analysis and Solution of Abnormal Wear of Cylinder Head and Exhaust Valve Seat in Marine Diesel Engine

Nov 16, 2024

After about 60 hours of maintenance and operation of a certain type of marine main propulsion diesel engine in W5, it was found that the clearance of the exhaust valves of 40 cylinders exceeded the tolerance, and 38 exhaust valve seats were worn beyond the repair limit of the cylinder head. After replacing 38 new cylinder heads and running for about 60 hours, a large area of exhaust valve seat wear occurred again, and 0 # automotive diesel was used for both navigation tests. Based on the fault phenomenon, list the fault tree of abnormal wear of cylinder head and exhaust valve seat, and analyze and troubleshoot it from three aspects: maintenance and installation, component quality, and usage conditions.

 

Analyzing and judging the fault mechanism, the cause of the fault is the use of 0 # automotive diesel with low sulfur content, which failed to form an effective anti-wear layer and accelerated the wear of the exhaust valve seat. Corresponding solutions are proposed for the abnormal wear of the diesel engine valve seat, providing a solution for subsequent analysis of similar faults.

 

In April 2019, a certain ship carried out repair work at the shipyard. Two MTU956V20 diesel engines were repaired and maintained according to the W5 level standard (each operated for about 5800 hours before the repair, and during the repair, two cylinder heads were replaced due to exhaust valve seat wear exceeding the cylinder head repair limit). In September, after completing the W5 level repair and installation, the diesel engine could not start when in use for about 60 hours. After inspection, it was found that the valve clearances of 40 cylinders exceeded the tolerance, and 38 exhaust valve seats were worn beyond the cylinder head repair limit. After replacing 38 new cylinder heads in November and using them for about 60 hours, there was a large area of exhaust valve seat wear again. Both navigation tests used 0 # automotive diesel. After replacing 9 cylinder heads for the second time, a certain ship used -10 # diesel for navigation tests and subsequent tasks, interspersed with 0 # automotive diesel (mainly 10 # diesel). As of December 2020, it has been running for about 1000 hours (accumulated running time of about 6900 hours) without any abnormal wear or failure of cylinder head and exhaust valve seat.

 

When the diesel engine is running, the camshaft drives the exhaust valve to open according to the set valve timing through the tappet and rocker arm mechanism for exhaust, and then closes under the action of the valve spring. The design of MTU956 diesel engine pursues lightweight, high power and low density. There is no hard heat-resistant alloy valve seat ring embedded in the intake and exhaust valve seats of the cylinder head. The valve seat and cylinder head are integrated and made of cast iron material; The exhaust valve is equipped with a rotary valve mechanism, and the air valve rotates under the action of the rotary valve mechanism every time it is opened. During operation, the exhaust valve seat surface temperature is around 300-350 ℃ due to the flushing of high-temperature gas and exhaust airflow inside the cylinder. When the valve is closed and seated, it will hit the surface of the valve at a certain speed. When the diesel engine speed is 1450r/min, the valve seating speed is 0.2m/s and the impact is 727 times/min. The surface of the exhaust valve seat is subjected to high temperature and high contact stress impact during operation, resulting in harsh working conditions.

 

The inspection and repair process in the MTU 956 cylinder head repair process specification is consistent with the MTU V956/1163 TB.2 maintenance manual. The protrusion data of the air valve installed on the valve seat is generally between 4.80~5.10 mm (the limit standard is 3.0 mm), and the reinstallation quality meets the requirements of the MTU V956/1163 TB.2 maintenance manual. After the first malfunction occurred, after replacing 38 new cylinder heads and running for about 60 hours, the problem of abnormal wear of the cylinder head valve seat occurred again, thus ruling out the possibility of improper repair causing the malfunction.

 

Inspection of product manufacturing and assembly records, re examination of inspection and assembly inspection records of relevant parts of the faulty machine, original records of the cylinder head for the first failure, inspection of the dimensions of the cylinder head water chamber, air chamber, and valve seat, and inspection of the fit between the intake and exhaust valves and valve seats; Check the sealing of the cylinder head, the depth of the valve seat, and the integrity of the cylinder head, and ensure that the assembly quality of the components meets the technical requirements.

 

Performance investigation of cylinder head valve material. After the first malfunction, A1 and B6 cylinders with severe exhaust valve seat wear were extracted, and the Shanghai Mechanical Engineering Society Failure Analysis Professional Committee was commissioned to conduct hardness testing on the working surfaces of the exhaust valve and valve seat, as well as metallographic testing on the working surfaces of the valve seat. The exhaust valve drawing number of MTU956 diesel engine is 580 053 02 05, and the hardness requirement is ≥ 280HB (equivalent to Rockwell hardness of 29.2HCR, with HB and HV values similar). The hardness values of the exhaust valves of A1 and B6 cylinders are shown in Table 1, and the valve hardness is much higher than the required value, but it meets the requirements of the valve technical documents.

 

The technical document for MTU956 diesel engine cylinder head requires a pearlite matrix with pearlite content greater than 95%; The hardness requirement is 200~260HB (199.5~262.5HV, HB=(HV+10.5)/1.05). The hardness results of the exhaust valve seats of A1 and B6 cylinders are shown in Table 2. The measured hardness of the cylinder head valve seat is slightly higher than the design requirement.

 

The analysis results of the exhaust valve and valve seat issued by the Failure Analysis Professional Committee of the Shanghai Mechanical Engineering Society show that: 1) the sealing surface hardness (at a distance of 0.1 mm from the surface) and hardness gradient of the exhaust valve are relatively uniform. 2) There is no significant difference in the hardness gradient between the exhaust valve seat and the intake valve seat. Due to the presence of graphite in the matrix, there are fluctuations in the tested hardness, which is a normal phenomenon. 3) The metallographic structure of the working surfaces of the exhaust valve seat and intake valve seat is composed of pearlite, a small amount of iron element, and a very small amount of carbon element. The test results show that the hardness of the exhaust valve at room temperature meets the requirements, and the hardness of the measuring points on the exhaust valve seat is slightly higher than the required value. The metallographic structure meets the technical requirements.

 

The impact force between the air valve and the valve seat depends on the seating speed of the air valve, which is influenced by the camshaft profile of the intake and exhaust valves. According to the third replacement of the cylinder head, the diesel engine ran for about 1000 hours without any abnormalities, and the abnormal wear of the exhaust valve seat was eliminated. Therefore, the possibility of abnormal wear of the cylinder head valve seat caused by the valve transmission mechanism and camshaft is basically ruled out.

 

In the W5 maintenance, the factory inspected the cylinder head rotary valve mechanism and found that it was operating normally. After the first malfunction, 38 new cylinder head assemblies were replaced, but a large number of cylinder head wear faults still occurred in the short term. Therefore, the possibility of the rotary valve mechanism causing the malfunction is basically ruled out.

 

During the inspection of the diesel engine operating conditions from maintenance to the first malfunction of W5, and from the replacement of the new cylinder head to the second malfunction, no abnormal wear of the cylinder head was found, and no widespread abnormal wear of the cylinder head occurred during the use of W5 before maintenance and after the second malfunction was replaced with -10 diesel. The basic judgment is that the operating conditions will have an impact on the wear of the valve seat, but it is not the direct cause of this malfunction. The MTU956 diesel engine is designed with a lubrication pump in the intake pipe, which can lubricate the intake valve. By checking that the oil pump is working properly and there is no abnormal wear on the intake valve seat, lubrication quality issues can be ruled out. The ship used 0 # automotive diesel as fuel after W5 maintenance, and did not use any additives, which meets the requirements of GB19147-2013. However, the sulfur content is too low (≤ 10 mg/kg), which does not meet the technical specifications of MTU.

 

Entrust the Lanzhou Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences to analyze the additives, LUBRIZLO ®ADX766M The diesel additive is a mixture of potassium salt and solvent, with the solid substance being potassium docetate and the solvent being solvent oil of 200 # fatty hydrocarbons. Entrust Lanzhou Institute of Chemical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, to conduct SEM appearance and EDS composition analysis on the sealing surface of the exhaust valve, and select the exhaust valve under four conditions for inspection. SEM observation and composition analysis of the faulty exhaust valve and valve seat sealing surface revealed that the surface of the exhaust valve sealing surface was rough, with adhesion to the cylinder head substrate. The cylinder head valve seat sealing surface was flat, while the cast iron substrate exhibited plastic flow and adhesive tearing. The exhaust valve has not experienced wear, and the abnormally worn part is the cylinder head and exhaust valve seat. The cylinder head of 956 diesel engine is made of special alloy cast iron, which has poor wear resistance. In the absence of surface facial mask protection, the tangential stress caused by the direct contact of metal causes the rapid fatigue peeling of its matrix and wear; Meanwhile, due to the unreasonable matching of the hardness difference between the air valve and the valve seat, the high hardness of the air valve further exacerbates wear. According to the above test results, the main component of the anti-wear layer on the sealing surface of the four schemes is amorphous carbon. After combustion, large particles form an anti-wear layer on the valve seat surface to separate the sealing surfaces of the exhaust valve and the valve seat. By avoiding direct contact between the sealing surfaces and reducing adhesive wear, wear is suppressed.

 

According to the reference Valve Seat Treatment – An Independent Review of Existing Data provided by Shaanxi Diesel Engine Heavy Industry Co., Ltd., combined with the previous failures of valve seat wear and the formation mechanism of surface facial mask, it can be seen that the surface facial mask of sealing surface belongs to a dynamic consumption film. Under low working conditions, the formation rate of the surface facial mask is greater than the removal rate, and the protection ability of the exhaust valve group is strengthened; Under high operating conditions, the formation rate is less than the removal rate, and the ability to protect the exhaust valve seat gradually decreases. It can be explained why the ship did not malfunction for thousands of hours before the maintenance of the W5 diesel engine, but quickly experienced repeated malfunctions 60 hours after repair. This is due to the use of high sulfur fuel and additives during the early factory testing period, and the use of high sulfur fuel during the trial voyage, which formed a more rigorous protective film to protect the valve seat.

 

According to the historical usage status of two 956 diesel engines, they were operated on -10 # diesel with added anti-wear agent as fuel for about 50 hours during the factory test stage at Shaanxi Diesel Engine Heavy Industry Co., Ltd. Before sailing to Sanya, they were operated on -10 # diesel for about 100 hours. Combined with the analysis results, it is indicated that a dense surface protective film has formed on the exhaust valve seat sealing surface before applying 0 # automotive diesel in Sanya. Therefore, no abnormal wear occurred during the approximately 5000 hour voyage in Sanya. During the W5 maintenance, the exhaust valve and valve seat were repaired, resulting in the removal of the above surface facial mask. After the maintenance, 0 # low sulfur vehicle diesel was used for operation, and no surface facial mask was formed, which caused abnormal wear of subsequent valve seats.

 

Based on the analysis of the cause of the malfunction and the current situation of the use of this type of diesel engine, the following recommended measures are proposed: it is necessary to determine whether the diesel meets the requirement of sulfur content greater than 500mg/kg before use; By installing an anti-wear additive storage and addition device in the diesel engine compartment, it is possible to automatically add additives to the daily fuel tank, meeting the requirements for driving diesel engines. From the perspective of thoroughly solving the problem of valve seat wear in the long run, it is necessary to improve the wear resistance of the cylinder head exhaust valve seat. The cylinder head generally adopts a nested valve seat to improve the wear resistance and service life of the valve and valve seat. It is recommended that domestic diesel engine research institutes or diesel engine manufacturers carry out research on cylinder head modification schemes, complete the development and production of new cylinder heads, and the improved design scheme of the cylinder head has mature applications, and the technical risks of the improved design are controllable.

 

info-1280-744

 

Send Inquiry